Xarigga Pro Ref: Goolka Man City ee Man Utd waa 'khalad xisaabeed' oo la aqoonsaday
Xarigga ciyaaraha Pro Ref wuxuu aqoonsaday in goolka Erling Haaland ee Man City ay ka gaartay Man Utd uu ahaa khalad xisaabeed, isagoo sheegay in VAR lahaa inuu ku celcelin lahaa xisaabta ciyaarta.
Xaqiiqada ciyaarta iyo go'aanka VAR
Ciyaartii Man Utd iyo Man City ee ka dhacday Old Trafford ayaa ku dhamaatay 1-0, iyadoo Man City ay guulaysatay goolka Erling Haaland ee 60-aadka daqiiqadda. Goolkan ayaa markii hore la diiday ciyaarta, laakiin VAR wuxuu go'aansaday in Haaland uu ku jiray meel dhexe ah.
Pro Ref wuxuu sheegay in Enzo Fernandez uu ku jiray meel dhexe ah, laakiin wuxuu sheegay inuu uusan goolka ka qayb qaadanin. Hase yeeshee, qorshaha ciyaaraha wuxuu sheegayaa in qofka dhexe ee ciyaarta ku jira uu khalad ku noqon karo isagoo uusan goolka ka qayb qaadanin.
Qoraalka Pro Ref iyo hadalka kooxda
Pro Ref wuxuu sheegay inuu la xiriiray Man Utd si uu u aqoonsado khaladda, isagoo sheegay in VAR lahaa inuu ku celcelin lahaa xisaabta ciyaarta. Gary Neville wuxuu sheegay inuu rajeynayo in Pro Ref uu soo saaro eedeysiga, isagoo sheegay in Enzo Fernandez uu uusan goolka ka qayb qaadanin.
Lisandro Martinez wuxuu sheegay in goolku uusan ku dhicin, isagoo sheegay inuu ahaa khalad. Micah Richards wuxuu sheegay in goolka uu ahaa mid aan la aqoonin, isagoo sheegay in Enzo Fernandez uu uusan goolka ka qayb qaadanin.
Hadalka carruurta iyo khaladka ugu weyn
Roy Keane wuxuu sheegay in Enzo Fernandez uu uusan goolka ka qayb qaadanin, isagoo sheegay in Man Utd ay uusan goolka ka qayb qaadanin. Jamie Carragher wuxuu sheegay in goolku uu ahaa mid khalad ah, isagoo sheegay inuu ahaa khaladka ugu weyn ee la arkay.
Carragher wuxuu sheegay in khaladka Liverpool uu ahaa mid khalad ah, laakiin khaladka Man Utd uu ahaa mid khalad ah. Wuxuu sheegay in khaladka Liverpool uu ahaa mid khalad ah, laakiin khaladka Man Utd uu ahaa mid khalad ah.
Refereeing body Pro Ref has acknowledged an error of judgment after awarding Erling Haaland's winning goal in Manchester City's 1-0 victory at Old Trafford, prompting widespread criticism from pundits and players alike.
Pro Ref Issues Official Apology
Pro Ref released a statement hours after the match, confirming that the VAR should have recommended an on-field review before awarding the goal. The body admitted the decision was an error of judgment and said it had contacted Manchester United to acknowledge the mistake. Despite the apology, United will take no further action but remain hugely frustrated by the incident.
The goal was initially disallowed for offside on the pitch before VAR overturned the decision, ruling that Haaland was in an onside position. However, VAR also determined that Enzo Fernandez did not play the ball, which became the basis for the goal being awarded despite Fernandez's offside position and apparent interference with the defending.
Pundits and Players Criticise the Decision
Gary Neville predicted Pro Ref would issue an apology and insisted Enzo Fernandez was attempting to play the ball and putting Lisandro Martinez off. Micah Richards dismissed the Match Centre explanation as nonsense, stating Fernandez was clearly challenging for the ball. Roy Keane concluded that Fernandez was interfering with play and United were punished for holding a good defensive line.
Jamie Carragher admitted the decision was a bad one and called it a huge error, comparing it to the Luis Diaz vs Tottenham VAR mistake. Lisandro Martinez said the goal should not have stood and called it an injustice, while Carragher believed the Liverpool incident was worse due to its communication failure.
Match Centre Statement Under Fire
The Premier League Match Centre explained that VAR checked the referee's offside call and determined Haaland was in an onside position, while also deeming Fernandez did not play the ball. However, this explanation drew sharp criticism as it overlooked the offside rule's provision that a player can interfere with an opponent without touching the ball.
The incident drew comparisons to the Luis Diaz vs Tottenham VAR error, where the Colombian was wrongly ruled offside. Carragher believes the Liverpool mistake was worse, noting the Haaland goal was a huge error in one of the biggest games in the league and around the world.
Ilaha iyo xuquuqda sawirka
Sawir: Sky Sports Football Xigasho
