Goolkii ay dhaleen Manchester United iyo Ipswich Town oo sharci darteed la ogolaaday

VAR waxay caddeysay in gacan-qabsashada aan khatarta ahayn aysan ciwaanka u ahayn marka uu difaacahu isku gooyo

Harry Maguire ayaa isku dayay gool ka dhan ah Ipswich Town, laakiin kubaddu waxay ka dhuftay gacantiisa ka dibna uu u dhaqaaqay sanduuqa. Isaguna goolkii ma uusan dhalin, laakiin wuxuu ka leexday Jacob Greaves oo isku gooyay, sidaa darteedna waxaa loo tiriyay gool iskiis ah.

Go'aanka VAR iyo Sharciyada Gacan-qabsashada

Sawir-qaadehii fiidiyowga Jarred Gillett ayaa u sheegay garsooraha Craig Pawson inuu yiraahdo: 'It's an own goal and the accidental handball is not punishable, so we recommend you award the goal.'. Tani waxay muujinaysaa in gacan-qabsashada shil ah ee dhaliyaha aan la ciqaabin marka ay dhacdo xaaladaha qaar.

Sharciyadu waxay leeyihiin saddex meelood oo aan gacan-qabsashada shil ah ee dhaliyaha loo tirin: goolkii uusan isla markiiba dhicin, goolkii uu dhaliyo saaxiib, ama ficil difaac ah oo keena gool iskiis ah. Xaaladdan, Greaves ayaa isku gooyay, sidaa darteedna goolkii waa la ogolaaday.

Natiijada Ciyaarta iyo Falanqaynta Tababarayaasha

Manchester United ayaa ku guuleysatay ciyaarta 5-2 iyadoo Bruno Fernandes uu dhaliyay seddex gool. Gary O'Neil oo ah maamulaha Ipswich ayaa u sheegay Sky Sports inay tahay 'tough for a referee' inuu xukumo sharci 'complicated rule'.

Paul Robinson ayaa ku yiri BBC Radio 5 Live: 'Once again we are victims of the law'. Darren Bent wuxuu raaciyay: 'It's one of those rules where I understand because it's there in black and white, but it still doesn't feel right.'.

Tusaale La Mid ah Oo Hore U Dhacay

Bishii January 2023, xaalad la mid ah ayaa dhacday markii Brentford ay gool ka dhalisay Liverpool, laakiin Ben Mee ayaa kubaddu uga dhuftay gacantiisa shil ah, ka dibna uu ka leexday Ibrahima Konate oo isku gooyay.

Tusaalahaas wuxuu muujinayaa in sharciyada gool-dhalinta ay marar dhif ah la mid yihiin, laakiin ay si joogto ah u dhaqan geliyaan marka difaacuhu isku gooyo kaddib gacan-qabsasho shil ah. Caymiska VAR ayaa haga xukunka ku salaysan qoraalka sharciyada.

Manchester United's opening goal against Ipswich Town was allowed to stand after VAR Jarred Gillett confirmed the ball deflected off Jacob Greaves, making it an own goal despite Harry Maguire's initial contact with his arm.

The Goal and the VAR Decision

Harry Maguire struck the ball with his arm before moving into the penalty area and shooting toward the net. However, the effort went wide and deflected off Ipswich defender Jacob Greaves, resulting in an own goal rather than a Maguire strike. The ball's trajectory and the involvement of a teammate's action meant the goal was technically valid under the handball exemption rules.

VAR Jarred Gillett reviewed the incident and advised referee Craig Pawson that the accidental handball was not punishable. Gillett stated: 'It's an own goal and the accidental handball is not punishable, so we recommend you award the goal.' The decision hinged on the fact that Maguire did not directly score, and the ball's path was altered by another player's intervention.

Match Outcome and Reactions

Manchester United secured a 5-2 victory over Ipswich Town, with Bruno Fernandes delivering a hat-trick to seal the win. Ipswich boss Gary O'Neil acknowledged the difficulty of the ruling, telling Sky Sports: 'It's tough for a referee' to judge on what is a 'complicated rule.' The decision drew mixed reactions from pundits and former players alike.

Former England goalkeeper Paul Robinson commented on BBC Radio 5 Live: 'Once again we are victims of the law.' Ex-Ipswich forward Darren Bent added: 'It's one of those rules where I understand because it's there in black and white, but it still doesn't feel right.' Both highlighted the frustration the handball law can cause, even when technically applied correctly.

Historical Context and Rule Complexity

A similar scenario unfolded in January 2023 when Brentford scored against Liverpool. The ball came off Ben Mee's arm but deflected off Ibrahima Konate for an own goal, mirroring the Maguire incident. This precedent reinforced the VAR's decision, as the exemption for accidental handball leading to an own goal had been applied consistently in past matches.

The handball law remains one of the most debated rules in football, with exemptions designed to prevent overly strict interpretations. While the VAR officials enforce the law as written, the complexity often leaves fans and pundits questioning the spirit of the rule. The Maguire case underscored the fine line between technical compliance and perceived fairness.